You should pay extra toward your mortgage principal before adding extra to your escrow account, because extra principal reduces the loan balance and the total interest you pay, while extra escrow only builds a cushion for future bills. This article explains the difference, how each option works, and how to decide based on your situation.
Formula
The calculator above shows two scenarios: your base monthly payment and the interest you would pay over the full term, then the same with an extra monthly principal payment. The base payment is the standard amortization formula:
M = P × (r × (1 + r)^n) / ((1 + r)^n – 1)
Where:
- M = monthly payment (dollars)
- P = loan principal (dollars)
- r = monthly interest rate = APR / 1200 (decimal)
- n = number of months = years × 12
To find the number of months to pay off with an extra payment, use: months = ceil( -ln(1 – r × P / M_extra) / ln(1 + r) ), where M_extra is your base payment plus the extra amount. The total interest with extra payments is (M_extra × months) – P – (extra × months).
Worked Example
Using the default values: loan amount $200,000, APR 6.5%, term 30 years, extra $100 per month.
First, the monthly rate r = 6.5 / 1200 = 0.0054166667.
Base payment M = 200000 × (0.0054166667 × (1.0054166667)^360) / ((1.0054166667)^360 – 1) = $1,264.14 (rounded to the cent).
Total interest without extra = 1264.14 × 360 – 200000 = $255,090.40.
With an extra $100, M_extra = 1364.14. Months to payoff = ceil( -ln(1 – 0.0054166667 × 200000 / 1364.14) / ln(1.0054166667) ) = ceil( -ln(0.2058) / 0.005401 ) = ceil( 295.3 ) = 296 months.
Total interest with extra = (1364.14 × 296) – 200000 – (100 × 296) = 403,785.44 – 200000 – 29,600 = $174,185.44.
Interest saved = 255,090.40 – 174,185.44 = $80,904.96.
Assumptions
- Fixed interest rate for the entire loan term.
- Payments are made monthly at the end of each period.
- Interest compounds monthly at APR / 12.
- Extra payments are applied directly to principal, not to interest or escrow.
- No fees, taxes, insurance, PMI, or escrow are included in the calculation.
What Is Escrow and How Does It Work?
Escrow is an account held by your mortgage servicer that collects money for property taxes and homeowners insurance. Each month, a portion of your payment goes into escrow, and the servicer pays those bills when they come due. Lenders require escrow for most conventional loans when your down payment is below 20%, and for all FHA loans. The escrow amount is not fixed; it can change annually based on your actual tax and insurance costs. If your taxes rise, your monthly escrow payment rises too.
Extra escrow payments are usually voluntary, but they do not reduce your loan balance. They simply add a cushion to the escrow account so that if your taxes or insurance premiums increase, you have a buffer. However, lenders generally limit how much extra you can keep in escrow—often around two months of escrow payments—and any excess is refunded to you.
How Extra Principal Payments Work
When you make an extra payment and specify it goes to principal, that amount directly reduces the outstanding loan balance. This has two effects: you pay less interest over the life of the loan, and you build home equity faster. The interest savings come because interest is calculated on the remaining balance; a lower balance means less interest accrues each month. Even a modest extra payment, like $50 per month, can shave years off your mortgage and save thousands in interest.
For example, on a $200,000 loan at 6.5% for 30 years, an extra $100 per month reduces the payoff time from 360 months to about 296 months and saves roughly $80,900 in interest, as shown in the calculator.
How to Choose Between Extra Principal and Extra Escrow
The decision depends on your cash flow and your financial goals. Here are factors to consider:
- Emergency fund: If you have less than three months of living expenses saved, build that first before making extra payments of any kind.
- Escrow shortage: If your escrow account is short because taxes increased, you may need to cover that shortage to avoid a higher monthly payment. In that case, paying extra to escrow is necessary, not optional.
- Interest rate: If your mortgage rate is high (say above 6%), extra principal is more valuable because you save more interest. If your rate is very low (below 4%), you might prefer investing the extra money elsewhere.
- Loan term: Extra principal has a bigger impact on a 30-year loan than on a 15-year loan because there is more time for interest to compound.
- PMI removal: If you pay PMI, extra principal can help you reach 20% equity faster, which lets you request PMI removal and lower your monthly payment.
Common Mistakes and Misconceptions
One common mistake is assuming that any extra payment automatically goes to principal. You must specify “principal only” when you make the payment, or the servicer may apply it to interest or escrow. Another misconception is that extra escrow payments reduce your interest or shorten your loan—they do not. Escrow is just a savings account for future bills; it has no effect on your loan balance.
Another error is forgetting that extra principal payments do not lower your monthly payment unless you recast. If you pay extra principal, your required monthly payment stays the same, but you pay off the loan faster. If you want a lower monthly payment, you need to request a loan recast, which usually requires a lump-sum principal payment and a fee.
Finally, do not neglect your escrow account entirely. If you fall short, the lender will cover the shortage and then increase your monthly payment to catch up, which can strain your budget.
Costs and Safety Considerations
Extra principal payments have no direct cost, but they tie up cash that you might need for other expenses. There is no penalty for prepaying most conventional mortgages, but some loans have prepayment penalties—check your loan documents. Extra escrow payments also have no fee, but they are refundable if you overpay, and they do not earn interest for you.
Safety-wise, always confirm with your servicer that extra payments are applied to principal. Keep records of your statements. If you are in a tight cash flow situation, prioritize an emergency fund before making extra payments. The calculation above is an estimate; your lender’s disclosure gives the exact figures for your loan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I put extra money into escrow to lower my monthly payment?
No, extra escrow does not lower your monthly payment. It only builds a cushion. Your monthly payment is based on your loan amortization plus the escrow estimate, and extra escrow does not change the loan balance or interest.
Is it better to pay extra principal or make a lump-sum payment?
Both reduce your principal, but a lump-sum payment has a larger immediate effect on interest because it reduces the balance all at once. The math is the same: every dollar of principal reduces future interest, regardless of whether it comes monthly or as a lump sum.
Will extra principal payments remove PMI faster?
Yes, extra principal payments help you reach 20% equity sooner, which is the threshold to request PMI removal on conventional loans. Once your loan-to-value ratio hits 80%, you can ask your servicer to cancel PMI.
What happens if I overpay my escrow?
If your escrow balance exceeds the allowed cushion (usually two months of payments), your servicer will refund the excess to you. You do not lose the money, but it does not earn interest.
Should I pay extra principal if I have high-interest credit card debt?
Generally, it makes sense to pay off higher-interest debt first, since credit card rates are often much higher than mortgage rates. The interest savings from paying down a 20% credit card outweigh the savings from a 6% mortgage.
Can I change my escrow payments during the year?
Your escrow payment is set annually based on your tax and insurance bills. You can make voluntary extra payments, but your required monthly amount will not change until the annual escrow analysis, unless you request a voluntary escrow payment.
This result is an estimate for educational purposes; your lender’s disclosure gives the exact figures for your loan.
Related
Formula used
in p | Loan amount | $ | 200000 | 1 | 10000000 in apr | Interest rate (APR) | % | 6.5 | 0.01 | 100 in yrs | Loan term | years | 30 | 1 | 50 in extra | Extra monthly principal | $ | 100 | 0 | 10000 out pmt | Base monthly payment | $ | p * (apr / 1200) / (1 - (1 + apr / 1200) ^ -(yrs * 12)) | 2 out tot | Total interest (no extra) | $ | pmt * yrs * 12 - p | 2 out newtot | Total interest (with extra) | $ | (pmt + extra) * (ceil(round(-ln(1 - apr / 1200 * p / (pmt + extra)) / ln(1 + apr / 1200), 6))) - p - extra * (ceil(round(-ln(1 - apr / 1200 * p / (pmt + extra)) / ln(1 + apr / 1200), 6))) | 2 out saved | Interest saved | $ | tot - newtot | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard loan formula for this calculation, fixed rate and monthly compounding unless stated, rounded as each result states. Not financial advice; no lender, rate or product is recommended. See formulas and assumptions, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- QNB Car Loan Payment Calculator and Guide$405.53
- Car Loan Payment Calculator and Formula$405.53
- VA Down Payment Assistance Calculator and Guide$15,000.00
- Low Down Payment Home Loans: Costs and Trade-Offs$405.53
- Down Payment vs Advance Payment: Key Differences
- DIB Bank Car Loan Calculator and Payment Guide$405.53