For an O-5 (Lieutenant Colonel or Commander) retiring with 20 years of active duty, the standard monthly retired pay under the High-36 system is 50% of the average of your highest 36 months of basic pay. Under the Blended Retirement System (BRS), it is 40% of that same average, plus a government match to your Thrift Savings Plan (TSP). The exact dollar amount depends on your pay grade, years of service, and the pay tables in effect during your high-36 window.
How Military Retirement Pay Is Calculated
There are two main retirement systems for active-duty members, and your pay depends on which one you fall under. The legacy system is called High-36 (or “Final Pay” if you entered before September 8, 1980). The newer system is the Blended Retirement System (BRS), which applies to anyone who entered service on or after January 1, 2018, and to those who opted in before the deadline.
- High-36: Retired pay = 2.5% × years of service × average of your highest 36 months of basic pay.
- BRS: Retired pay = 2.0% × years of service × average of your highest 36 months of basic pay, plus TSP matching contributions (up to 5% of base pay) during your career.
- Final Pay: Same as High-36, but the multiplier is applied to your final basic pay (only for those who entered before September 8, 1980).
For 20 years of service, the multiplier is 50% under High-36 and 40% under BRS. The “high-36” average is taken from the three consecutive years (36 months) when your basic pay was highest, typically the last three years of service.
Example: O-5 with 20 Years in 2025
To give you a concrete sense, let’s use the 2025 active-duty basic pay tables (which were effective January 1, 2025). An O-5 with 20 years of service is paid at the “Over 20” pay rate, which is $12,980.10 per month. If they retire under High-36, their high-36 average is likely close to that amount (assuming no major pay raises in the prior years).
Using the High-36 formula:
- Monthly retired pay = 50% × $12,980.10 = $6,490.05
- Annual retired pay = $6,490.05 × 12 = $77,880.60
Under BRS, the same O-5 would receive 40% × $12,980.10 = $5,192.04 per month, but they would also have received TSP matching contributions during their career (up to 5% of base pay) that could grow into a substantial nest egg. Note that the actual high-36 average might be slightly lower if pay raises were smaller in earlier years, but for a 20-year O-5, the difference is usually minor.
Factors That Affect Your Exact Pay
Several variables can change your retired pay from the simple 50% calculation:
- Pay raises: Your high-36 average is based on the basic pay tables in effect during those 36 months. If you had a promotion or a large raise, your average could be higher than a straight 50% of your final pay.
- Disability retirement: If you are retired for disability, you may receive tax-free compensation from the VA, but your retired pay may be offset (Concurrent Retirement and Disability Pay, or CRDP, can restore it under certain conditions).
- Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP): If you elect SBP coverage, your retired pay is reduced by a percentage (typically 6.5% of the base amount) to provide an annuity to your spouse or beneficiaries.
- Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLAs): Retired pay increases annually with inflation, so your initial amount will grow over time.
- State taxes: Some states do not tax military retired pay; others do. This affects your net income, not the gross amount.
How to Choose Between High-36 and BRS
If you are still serving and have the option to choose (or if you’re helping someone who does), the decision is not about which gives a higher monthly check at 20 years—it’s about long-term value. High-36 gives a larger monthly annuity, but BRS offers TSP matching that can be invested and grow over decades.
A rough comparison for an O-5 retiring at 20 years:
- High-36: $6,490/month for life, with COLAs.
- BRS: $5,192/month for life, plus TSP account that could be worth hundreds of thousands (or more) depending on contributions and investment returns.
If you expect to live a long time and value a guaranteed income, High-36 might be better. If you are a savvy investor and want flexibility, BRS could be more appealing. There is no one-size-fits-all answer; it depends on your financial goals and risk tolerance.
Common Misconceptions and Mistakes
One common mistake is assuming that retired pay is 50% of your final base pay. That’s only true if your high-36 average equals your final pay, which is often the case but not guaranteed. For example, if you had a pay freeze or a smaller raise in your last year, your average could be lower.
Another misconception is that BRS is always worse. While the monthly check is smaller, the TSP match is free money. Over a 20-year career, the match plus investment growth can be significant. For example, if you contributed 5% of your base pay and the government matched 5%, and your investments earned a modest 7% annual return, you could have over $200,000 in today’s dollars by retirement—enough to generate a monthly income that, when combined with the smaller pension, might exceed the High-36 pension.
Also, many people forget that retired pay is taxable (unless it’s VA disability), so the net amount is lower than the gross. Plan accordingly.
How to Get an Exact Estimate
The best way to get your exact retired pay is to use the official Defense Finance and Accounting Service (DFAS) Retired Pay Calculator or the myPay system. You can also request a retirement estimate from your service’s personnel office. These tools use your actual pay records and will give you a precise number.
If you want to do a quick estimate yourself, follow these steps:
- Find your high-36 average basic pay (use the pay tables for the years you’re considering).
- Multiply by your multiplier (0.50 for High-36, 0.40 for BRS, or 2.5% × years for Final Pay).
- That’s your monthly gross retired pay before any deductions (like SBP).
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an O-5 with 20 years get more than 50% if they have combat service?
No. Combat service does not increase the percentage multiplier. However, if you have combat-related disabilities, you may qualify for tax-free disability compensation from the VA, which can be received in addition to retired pay (subject to offset rules).
Is retired pay the same as the VA disability pay?
No. Retired pay is earned through years of service and is taxable (unless waived for disability). VA disability compensation is tax-free and is paid by the Department of Veterans Affairs for service-connected disabilities. You can receive both, but there may be an offset unless you qualify for CRDP or CRSC.
Can I receive both military retired pay and a federal civilian pension?
Yes, you can, but there may be a reduction in your military retired pay if you also receive a federal civilian pension under the Civil Service Retirement System (CSRS) or the Federal Employees Retirement System (FERS). The rules are complex, so consult with a financial advisor or DFAS.
How does the Survivor Benefit Plan affect my retired pay?
If you elect SBP, your retired pay is reduced by a percentage (typically 6.5% of the base amount you choose to cover). For example, if you choose to cover $6,490, your monthly retired pay would be reduced by about $422, and your beneficiary would receive 55% of the base amount after your death.
What is the difference between High-36 and Final Pay?
Final Pay uses your final basic pay as the basis, while High-36 uses the average of your highest 36 months. For most retirees, High-36 gives a slightly lower amount because the average is usually lower than the final pay. Final Pay only applies to those who entered before September 8, 1980.
Assumptions
This article uses the 2025 military basic pay tables for an O-5 with over 20 years of service. The high-36 average is assumed to be equal to the final basic pay for simplicity, which may not be exactly true. Retired pay estimates are gross amounts before taxes and any deductions like SBP. The actual amount is determined by DFAS based on your official pay records. Always consult the DFAS Retired Pay Calculator or your service’s finance office for a personalized estimate.
Related
General steps for current mainstream versions; menus can differ by device and version. See the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- Only Loans LLC: What It Is and How It Works$405.53
- Personal Loan and Interest Only Option?$133.33
- No Interest Personal Loan? What It Really Means$405.53
- Loans with Only a Bank Account: What You Need to Know
- Lending Money for Interest Only? Key Facts$133.33
- Land Only Loan: What It Is & How It Works$405.53