Home equity loans and cash-out refinancing have different costs: a home equity loan usually adds a separate loan with its own fees and payment, while a cash-out refinance replaces the existing mortgage and may involve a broader set of closing costs. This calculator compares estimated monthly payments and total interest for the two new borrowing options; enter each loan’s amount, APR, and term to see the arithmetic, not lender fees or your existing mortgage’s full payoff costs.
Formula
For each loan, the calculator finds the fixed monthly payment using the standard amortizing-loan formula:
Monthly payment = P × r ÷ [1 − (1 + r)−n]
- P is the loan amount in dollars.
- r is the monthly interest rate, calculated as APR ÷ 1,200 when APR is entered as a percentage per year.
- n is the number of monthly payments: loan term in years × 12.
The calculator rounds each monthly payment to cents. Total payments equal that rounded payment multiplied by the number of months. The home equity loan inputs and refinance inputs are calculated separately; the results do not subtract one loan’s cost from the other or include charges that are not entered.
Worked Example
Using the default inputs:
- Home equity loan: $50,000 at 8% APR for 15 years.
- Cash-out refinance: $300,000 at 7% APR for 30 years.
For the home equity loan, the monthly rate is 8 ÷ 1,200 = 0.0066667 and the term is 15 × 12 = 180 payments. Substituting into the formula gives an unrounded payment of about $477.83, or $477.83 per month to the nearest cent. Total payments are $477.83 × 180 = $86,009.40.
For the refinance, the monthly rate is 7 ÷ 1,200 = 0.0058333 and the term is 30 × 12 = 360 payments. The formula gives an unrounded payment of about $1,995.91, or $1,995.91 per month. Total payments are $1,995.91 × 360 = $718,527.60.
These totals illustrate why the amounts borrowed and repayment periods matter. They are not a direct comparison of borrowing the same amount: the refinance example includes a $300,000 loan, while the home equity example is $50,000.
Assumptions
- The entered APR and loan amount remain fixed for the entire term.
- Payments are level monthly payments, made at the end of each monthly period.
- Interest compounds monthly at APR ÷ 12.
- Fees, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, escrow, and any existing mortgage payoff details are not included.
What Each Option Costs
A home equity loan is generally a second loan secured by the home, separate from the existing mortgage. Its borrowing costs can include interest and lender or transaction charges; the new payment is usually in addition to the existing mortgage payment. A home equity line of credit is another form of home-secured borrowing, but it is revolving credit and may have changing rates and draw-period terms. This calculator models a fixed-rate, level-payment loan, not a line of credit.
With a cash-out refinance, the borrower takes a new mortgage larger than the amount needed to pay off the old mortgage and receives the difference, subject to transaction amounts and costs. The new loan has a new balance, APR, and term. Its payment shown here is for the full new loan—not merely the cash received. A longer term can lower the scheduled payment while increasing the number of months interest is paid.
Either transaction may involve charges such as an application or underwriting charge, an appraisal, title-related services, recording, or other closing items. Which charges apply and their amounts depend on the transaction and lender; use written loan estimates or disclosures for the figures that apply. Some costs may be paid upfront and others incorporated into the loan. If charges are added to the balance, the amount borrowed and interest paid can increase.
How to Compare Costs Fairly
First compare borrowing the same amount over the same term, using APR figures supplied for the actual offers. Then account for the existing mortgage separately. A refinance replaces it; a home equity loan generally sits alongside it. To understand total household payments, include the existing mortgage payment in the home-equity scenario, but do not add it to the refinance scenario after it has been paid off by the new loan.
- Compare upfront costs, including any charges paid in cash.
- Compare the new monthly payment and the total of scheduled payments over each loan’s full term.
- Check whether costs are financed, and include them in the amount borrowed if so.
- Account for the remaining balance and time left on the current mortgage; replacing a loan can restart the repayment schedule.
- Consider whether rates or payments can change. The calculator assumes a fixed APR and cannot represent variable-rate terms.
APR can help reflect certain borrowing costs in a standardized rate, but it does not necessarily capture every expense or make two offers directly comparable when their amounts, terms, or included charges differ. Review the loan documents and ask the lender which costs are included in its quoted figures.
Common Cost Misunderstandings
A lower monthly payment does not necessarily mean lower borrowing cost. It can result from borrowing less, a lower APR, or spreading repayment across more months. Compare total payments and fees alongside the monthly amount. Conversely, total payments alone do not account for when money is paid or the value of having cash available; the calculator is a basic arithmetic comparison, not a complete valuation.
Another common mistake is treating the cash received in a refinance as the refinance loan amount. The loan amount also pays off the old mortgage and may include financed charges. For a meaningful comparison, use the full proposed new balance for the refinance, and use only the separate amount being borrowed for the home equity loan. Do not interpret the example as a quote or as a prediction of eligibility.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a home equity loan cheaper than refinancing?
There is no universal answer. The costs depend on the amount borrowed, APR, term, fees, and the existing mortgage being replaced or retained. Compare actual written figures using matching assumptions.
Does refinancing reset the mortgage term?
A refinance creates a new loan with a new term. The term you enter determines the calculator’s payment schedule; the calculation does not account for the old loan’s remaining balance or months.
Does a cash-out refinance payment include the cash I receive?
The payment is calculated on the entire new refinance loan amount. That balance typically includes the amount used to pay off the prior mortgage as well as the cash-out portion and any financed costs.
Are closing costs included in this calculator?
No. It calculates principal-and-interest payments from the amount, APR, and term entered. Add any financed charges to the loan amount for a rough payment estimate, and assess upfront charges separately using lender-provided documents.
Can I compare a home equity line of credit with a refinance here?
Not accurately. A line of credit may have a variable APR, changing balance, and different repayment phases. This calculator assumes a fixed-rate loan with equal monthly payments.
This result is an estimate, and the lender’s disclosure gives the exact figures.
Related
Formula used
in heq | Home equity loan amount | $ | 50000 | 1 | 100000000 in hapr | Home equity APR | % | 8 | 0.01 | 100 in hyr | Home equity term | years | 15 | 0.0833 | 50 in ref | Cash-out refinance loan amount | $ | 300000 | 1 | 100000000 in rapr | Refinance APR | % | 7 | 0.01 | 100 in ryr | Refinance term | years | 30 | 0.0833 | 50 out hpmt | Home equity monthly payment | $ | round(heq * (hapr / 1200) / (1 - (1 + hapr / 1200) ^ -(hyr * 12)), 2) | 2 out rpmt | Refinance monthly payment | $ | round(ref * (rapr / 1200) / (1 - (1 + rapr / 1200) ^ -(ryr * 12)), 2) | 2 out htot | Home equity total payments | $ | hpmt * hyr * 12 | 2 out rtot | Refinance total payments | $ | rpmt * ryr * 12 | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard loan formula for this calculation, fixed rate and monthly compounding unless stated, rounded as each result states. Not financial advice; no lender, rate or product is recommended. See formulas and assumptions, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- Closing Costs on a House Loan: What to Expect$405.53
- Secured Loan for Home Refinancing: Payment Calculator$405.53
- Closing Cost House Calculator: Estimate Buyer Costs$8,500.00
- Closing Cost House Estimate Calculator
- Loan Repayment Extension Request Letter: What to Include$405.53
- Refinance Calculator With PMI and Loan Term