A home equity loan and a cash-out refinance can both turn home equity into borrowed money, but their closing costs are calculated differently: a home equity loan usually adds costs for a separate second mortgage, while a refinance replaces the existing mortgage and can involve a new, larger set of mortgage charges. This calculator compares estimated costs and the amount left after fees using figures you obtain from lenders; it does not determine which loan is suitable.
Formula
The first result is the refinance closing costs minus the home equity loan closing costs. A positive result means the entered refinance costs are higher; a negative result means the entered home equity loan costs are higher. This compares the costs entered, not interest, monthly payments, or total borrowing expense.
- Difference = refinance closing costs − home equity loan closing costs.
- Home equity loan proceeds after costs = home equity loan amount − home equity loan closing costs.
- Refinance cash after payoff and costs = home equity loan amount − existing mortgage payoff − refinance closing costs.
All money variables are in dollars: hl is the new home equity loan amount; hc is its estimated closing costs; rb is the amount required to pay off the current mortgage at refinance; and rc is estimated refinance closing costs. Enter lender-provided estimates on the same basis, and include any charges you want to compare consistently.
Worked Example
Using the calculator’s default inputs:
- Home equity loan amount: $50,000
- Home equity loan closing costs: $1,500
- Existing mortgage payoff: $200,000
- Refinance closing costs: $5,000
Difference = $5,000 − $1,500 = $3,500. With these inputs, refinance closing costs are $3,500 higher than home equity loan closing costs.
Home equity loan proceeds after costs = $50,000 − $1,500 = $48,500.
Refinance cash after payoff and costs = $50,000 − $200,000 − $5,000 = −$155,000. The negative figure is a useful warning that the example refinance amount would not cover the entered mortgage payoff and costs. It is not a feasible cash-out estimate as entered. For a realistic comparison, enter the proposed total refinance loan amount—not just the extra cash sought—in the refinance calculation. This calculator uses the home equity loan amount as a common new-borrowing figure for its simplified cash comparison, so the third output is only meaningful when that amount represents the proposed refinance loan amount.
What Closing Costs Include
Closing costs are charges associated with originating, processing, valuing, documenting, and completing a loan. Their exact names and amounts depend on the transaction and the lender’s itemized estimate. Possible line items include:
- Application, origination, or underwriting charges;
- Property appraisal or other valuation services;
- Credit, title search, title insurance, and settlement services;
- Recording, transfer, or other third-party charges where applicable;
- Prepaid interest, property-related insurance, or tax escrow funding, when required.
Do not assume every listed item applies. Some charges may be paid upfront, financed into the loan, or offset by a lender credit. A “no-closing-cost” offer generally changes how costs are paid or priced; it does not necessarily mean the transaction has no economic cost. Compare the written estimate and identify which charges are included in your calculator inputs.
How the Two Transactions Differ
A home equity loan is generally a separate loan secured by the home, in addition to the existing mortgage. Its closing costs relate to setting up that additional borrowing. The original mortgage remains in place, and the borrower has a separate payment obligation under the new loan. The calculator does not model either loan’s interest or payments.
A cash-out refinance replaces the existing mortgage with a new mortgage. The new loan typically has to account for the amount needed to pay off the existing mortgage as well as any cash-out amount and costs that are financed. Charges can therefore relate to a full mortgage refinancing transaction, not merely the additional cash. The payoff figure may differ from the current principal balance because it can include accrued interest or other amounts shown in the payoff quote.
That difference matters when comparing costs: comparing a second-mortgage estimate with only the refinance’s cash-out portion can be misleading. Compare equivalent transactions and use the refinance payoff quote and full itemized cost estimate.
How to Compare Estimates
- Request written, itemized cost estimates for the specific loan amounts and structures being considered.
- Separate charges paid at closing from prepaid items, escrow deposits, and any lender credits. Decide whether your comparison includes all cash due or only transaction fees.
- Enter fees consistently. If a fee is rolled into the loan, note that separately; the calculator’s simple subtraction does not determine its long-term interest cost.
- Compare more than upfront costs: review the loan amount, rate, payment, repayment term, and total interest using the lender’s disclosed figures. A lower initial cost alone does not establish a lower overall expense.
For example, if one estimate shows $2,000 in charges paid upfront and another shows $500 upfront plus $1,500 financed, the same nominal cost may have different cash-at-closing and long-term effects. This tool does not calculate financed-fee interest, recurring mortgage costs, or the value of keeping an existing loan.
Common Comparison Problems and Limits
- Mixing fee categories: Escrow deposits and prepaid items can increase cash due at closing but are not always comparable to lender or service charges. Label the amounts you enter.
- Using principal instead of payoff: A refinance pays the amount stated in a current payoff quote, not necessarily the balance displayed on a recent statement.
- Leaving out credits or financed fees: Show these separately or consistently net them against costs; otherwise the comparison may be distorted.
- Reading the result as a recommendation: The cost difference does not account for rates, payments, loan duration, tax treatment, or future plans. It is a subtraction, not a financial decision.
Estimates can change as details are verified, and actual charges depend on the transaction and lender disclosures. Ask the lender to clarify unfamiliar line items and whether figures are estimates, credits, prepaids, or amounts added to the loan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are home equity loan closing costs usually lower than refinance costs?
Not necessarily. The transactions involve different services and loan structures, and costs depend on the particular estimates. Compare itemized figures for the same borrowing need rather than assuming one type always costs less.
Does a refinance closing-cost estimate include paying off my mortgage?
The payoff is separate from closing costs, although the new loan must account for it. Use the lender’s payoff figure and the itemized refinance costs as separate amounts when evaluating the full transaction.
Can closing costs be added to the loan?
A lender may offer financing of some costs, subject to its terms and the transaction. Financing a charge reduces cash due upfront but increases the amount borrowed and may add interest. This calculator does not model that interest.
What does “no closing costs” mean?
It can mean costs are covered through a lender credit or reflected in other loan terms rather than paid as a separate upfront amount. Check the written estimate to see what is charged, credited, or financed.
Which number should I enter for refinance costs?
Use the total charges you intend to compare from the written refinance estimate, and treat escrow deposits, prepaids, and lender credits consistently with the other estimate. Ask the lender to explain ambiguous items.
Related
Formula used
in hl | Home equity loan amount | $ | 50000 | 1 | 100000000 in hc | Home equity loan closing costs | $ | 1500 | 0 | 100000000 in rb | Existing mortgage payoff | $ | 200000 | 0 | 100000000 in rc | Refinance closing costs | $ | 5000 | 0 | 100000000 out diff | Difference in closing costs (refinance minus home equity loan) | $ | rc - hc | 2 out hn | Home equity loan proceeds after costs | $ | hl - hc | 2 out rn | Refinance cash after payoff and costs | $ | hl - rb - rc | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard loan formula for this calculation, fixed rate and monthly compounding unless stated, rounded as each result states. Not financial advice; no lender, rate or product is recommended. See formulas and assumptions, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- Avalanche Game Schedule: Dates, Times and Where to Check
- Avalanche Hockey Schedule: Games, Dates and TV
- Avalanche Debt Payoff Tracker Calculator
- Avalanche Debt Repayment Calculator and Payoff Plan
- Avalanche Debt Payoff Calculator and Spreadsheet
- Avalanche Debt Payoff Calculator: Free Estimate