Federal student loans are generally the better first choice for most borrowers because they offer fixed rates, income-driven repayment plans, and forgiveness options, while private loans should only be considered after exhausting federal aid. This article compares the two so you can see which fits your situation. You enter your loan amount, interest rate, and term below to see the monthly payment and total interest for any loan you’re comparing.
Formula
The calculator uses the standard fixed-rate loan payment formula:
Monthly Payment = P × (r × (1 + r)^n) / ((1 + r)^n − 1)
Where:
- P = loan amount (principal) in dollars
- r = monthly interest rate = APR ÷ 12 (APR in decimal form, e.g., 8% becomes 0.08)
- n = total number of monthly payments = term in years × 12
Total interest is simply the monthly payment multiplied by the number of payments, minus the principal.
Worked Example
Using the default values: $20,000 loan, 8% APR, 5-year term.
- Monthly rate r = 8 / 1200 = 0.0066667
- Number of payments n = 5 × 12 = 60
- Payment = 20000 × (0.0066667 × (1.0066667)^60) / ((1.0066667)^60 − 1)
- (1.0066667)^60 ≈ 1.48985
- Numerator = 20000 × (0.0066667 × 1.48985) = 20000 × 0.0099323 = 198.65
- Denominator = 1.48985 − 1 = 0.48985
- Payment = 198.65 / 0.48985 ≈ 405.53
- Total interest = 405.53 × 60 − 20000 = 24331.80 − 20000 = 4331.80
The calculator shows a monthly payment of $405.53 and total interest of $4,331.80.
Assumptions
- Fixed interest rate for the entire term (private loans may have variable rates, but the calculator assumes fixed for comparison).
- Payments are made monthly at the end of each period.
- Interest compounds monthly at APR ÷ 12.
- No fees, origination charges, late penalties, or prepayment penalties are included—those would change the actual cost.
Background: How Federal and Private Loans Differ
Federal student loans are funded by the U.S. Department of Education. They come in several types: Direct Subsidized (for undergraduates with financial need, interest paid by the government while in school), Direct Unsubsidized (available to all students, interest accrues from day one), and Direct PLUS (for graduate students or parents). Private loans are offered by banks, credit unions, and online lenders. Their terms, rates, and protections vary widely by lender and by your credit profile.
The key difference is that federal loans are backed by the government, which allows them to offer borrower protections that private loans typically do not. These include income-driven repayment plans, loan forgiveness after a set number of qualifying payments, deferment and forbearance options, and in some cases, loan discharge due to disability or school closure. Private loans are governed by the individual contract, and lenders are not required to offer any of these flexibilities.
How It Works: The Application and Borrowing Process
To get a federal loan, you must complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA) each academic year. The government then sends you a financial aid offer listing the amounts you qualify for. You accept the loan, sign a Master Promissory Note, and the funds go to your school to cover tuition and fees first, with any leftover paid to you for other expenses.
Private loans require a separate application with each lender. The lender will check your credit score and may require a co-signer if you have little or no credit history. You apply for a specific amount, and the lender decides the interest rate (fixed or variable) and term based on your creditworthiness. The funds are typically sent directly to the school. You can borrow up to the school’s cost of attendance minus any other financial aid, but the lender sets its own minimum and maximum amounts.
How to Choose: Key Factors to Compare
When deciding between federal and private, consider these factors in order:
- Exhaust federal first: Max out federal loans before turning to private, because federal protections cannot be replicated by private lenders.
- Interest rates: Federal rates are set by Congress each year and are the same for every borrower; private rates depend on credit and can be lower or higher. Use the calculator above to compare the total cost at different rates.
- Repayment flexibility: Federal loans offer income-driven plans (payments capped at a percentage of income) and forgiveness after 20–25 years. Private loans rarely offer these.
- Deferment and forbearance: Federal loans allow you to pause payments during unemployment or economic hardship; private lenders may offer limited forbearance but not as a right.
- Co-signer requirement: Many students need a co-signer for private loans; federal loans do not require one (except PLUS loans, which have a credit check).
- Loan forgiveness programs: Only federal loans qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) if you work in qualifying public service jobs.
Common Problems and Misconceptions
One common misconception is that private loans are always cheaper because their advertised rates look lower. However, the lowest private rates are reserved for borrowers with excellent credit and a co-signer; many students end up with rates higher than federal rates. Another misconception is that you must choose one type—you can have both federal and private loans, but federal should be your base.
A frequent problem is borrowing more than needed. Students sometimes take the full amount offered, including private loans, without considering the long-term monthly payment. Use the calculator to see what a $5,000 difference in loan amount does to your payment. Another issue is ignoring the difference between fixed and variable rates. Federal loans are fixed, so your rate never changes. Private variable rates can start low but rise over time, increasing your payment unexpectedly.
Costs: Interest Rates and Fees
Federal loan interest rates are set annually by law and are fixed for the life of the loan. For example, in a recent year, undergraduate Direct loans had a rate around 5.5%, graduate loans around 7%, and PLUS loans around 8%. Private loan rates can range from below 4% to over 15% depending on credit, co-signer, and whether the rate is fixed or variable. Fees also differ: federal loans charge an origination fee (a percentage of the loan amount) that is deducted from the disbursement; private loans may have no origination fee but could have late fees or prepayment penalties. Always check the lender’s disclosure for the exact APR, which includes fees and reflects the true cost.
Safety and Borrower Protections
Federal loans offer several safety nets that private loans do not:
- Income-driven repayment: Your payment is based on income and family size, not just the balance.
- Loan forgiveness: After 20–25 years of qualifying payments, the remaining balance is forgiven (but may be taxable).
- Deferment: Temporarily stop payments for reasons like returning to school, unemployment, or economic hardship.
- Forbearance: Reduce or pause payments for up to 12 months at a time.
- Discharge: Loans may be discharged if the school closes, you become totally and permanently disabled, or in rare cases of death.
Private lenders are not required to offer any of these. Their forbearance programs are discretionary and often accrue interest while you’re not paying. If you default on a private loan, the lender can sue you and garnish wages without the same federal protections. Always read the private loan contract carefully to understand your rights.
Alternatives to Borrowing
Before taking any loan, consider other funding sources:
- Grants and scholarships (free money that doesn’t need repayment)
- Work-study programs or part-time jobs
- Tuition payment plans offered by the school
- Employer tuition assistance if you’re working
- Living at home or reducing expenses to lower the amount you need
If you still need to borrow, federal loans are the safer foundation. Private loans can fill gaps, but only after you’ve maximized federal aid and compared the total cost using the calculator above.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use both federal and private student loans?
Yes, you can have both. Many students take federal loans first, then use a private loan to cover any remaining gap. Just be aware that you’ll have separate payments and different servicers, and you’ll need to manage both.
What happens if I can’t make my private loan payment?
Contact your lender immediately. Some offer temporary forbearance or alternative repayment arrangements, but it’s not guaranteed. Missing payments can hurt your credit score and lead to default, which may result in wage garnishment or lawsuits. Federal loans offer more built-in protections like income-driven repayment.
Do federal loans have a credit check?
Most federal student loans (Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized) do not require a credit check. However, PLUS loans for graduate students or parents do require a credit check, and you must not have an adverse credit history. Private loans always require a credit check, and a co-signer is often needed if you have limited credit.
Can I refinance federal loans into a private loan?
Yes, you can refinance federal loans with a private lender, but doing so means you lose federal protections like income-driven repayment and forgiveness. It’s generally not recommended unless you have a high income, strong credit, and are certain you won’t need those protections. Once you refinance, you cannot switch back to federal.
How do I know what interest rate I’ll get on a private loan?
Private lenders give you a rate based on your credit score, income, and whether you have a co-signer. You’ll see a range of rates advertised, but your actual rate is determined after a hard credit check. You can use the calculator above to estimate payments at different rates, but the lender’s disclosure will give the exact APR.
This calculator provides an estimate for educational purposes; the lender’s official disclosure will show the exact payment and total cost for any loan you’re considering.
Related
Formula used
in p | Loan amount | $ | 20000 | 1 | 100000000 in apr | Interest rate (APR) | % | 8 | 0.01 | 100 in yrs | Loan term | years | 5 | 0.0833 | 50 out pmt | Monthly payment | $ | p * (apr / 1200) / (1 - (1 + apr / 1200) ^ -(yrs * 12)) | 2 out int | Total interest | $ | pmt * yrs * 12 - p | 2
Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work
Method: the standard loan formula for this calculation, fixed rate and monthly compounding unless stated, rounded as each result states. Not financial advice; no lender, rate or product is recommended. See formulas and assumptions, the disclaimer or report an error.
More in this section
- High Amount Personal Loan Interest Rate Calculator$405.53
- Jet Fuel Cost per Gallon? Prices and What Affects Them
- Fuel Costs and Home Loans: How They Connect$405.53
- Fuel Costs Perth: Prices, Factors and Savings
- Car Quote for a Used-Car Trade-In: What It Means
- Cost of Fuel: Calculate Your Trip’s Fuel Expense$42.00