calculate-loan

01 Loan payments

Cash-Out Refinance vs. HELOC: Compare Costs and Risks

Calculator No. 01-17834 · Updated · Formula and assumptions shown below

Monthly payment $405.53
Total interest
$4,331.67
= Monthly payment × loan term × 12 − new refinance loan amount
New refinance loan amount
$20,000
Input
Interest rate (APR)
8 %
Input
You enter
New refinance loan amount ($), Interest rate (APR) (%), Loan term (years)
You get
Monthly payment ($), Total interest ($)
Rounding
2 dp

Estimate for education, not financial advice. The result follows from the numbers you enter and the formula shown. It is not a quote or an offer, and it does not include fees, taxes or insurance unless the calculator asks for them. Ask your lender for the exact figures.

A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one and gives you part of the difference as cash; a home equity line of credit (HELOC) is a separate, usually revolving loan secured by your home. This comparison calculator estimates a cash-out refinance’s monthly principal-and-interest payment and total interest from the new loan amount, APR, and term; it does not calculate a HELOC payment, which depends on its balance, rate, and repayment terms.

Formula

The calculator applies the standard fixed-rate, fully amortizing loan payment formula. Monthly payment = P × r ÷ [1 − (1 + r)−n], where r = APR ÷ 1,200 and n = years × 12. Total interest is the monthly payment multiplied by the number of payments, minus the amount borrowed.

  • P is the new refinance loan principal, in dollars.
  • APR is the annual percentage rate entered as a percent.
  • r is the monthly rate as a decimal.
  • n is the number of monthly payments.

For this comparison, enter the proposed new mortgage balance—not merely the cash you expect to receive. A refinance loan may also pay off the existing mortgage and may include other amounts, depending on the transaction. The calculator does not determine those amounts.

Worked Example

Using the defaults: P = $20,000, APR = 8%, and term = 5 years.

  1. Monthly rate: r = 8 ÷ 1,200 = 0.0066667.
  2. Number of payments: n = 5 × 12 = 60.
  3. Monthly payment before rounding = 20,000 × 0.0066667 ÷ [1 − (1.0066667)−60] ≈ $405.53.
  4. Total interest = $405.53 × 60 − $20,000 = $4,331.80.

The calculator rounds the monthly payment to cents before calculating total interest. Minor differences can arise if intermediate values are rounded in the displayed steps.

Assumptions

  • The interest rate is fixed for the full term.
  • Payments are equal monthly payments made at the end of each period.
  • Interest compounds monthly at APR divided by 12.
  • Fees, taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance, escrow, and any costs of obtaining a loan are not included.
  • The calculation does not model a HELOC’s variable rate, draws, interest-only period, or changing balance.

How a Cash-Out Refinance and HELOC Work

With a cash-out refinance, the borrower takes out a new mortgage that pays off the prior mortgage. If the new balance is larger than the old payoff and any amounts financed, the remaining proceeds can be paid to the borrower. The new loan has its own rate, term, payment schedule, and closing costs. The original mortgage is replaced rather than retained.

A HELOC is a second loan secured by home equity, while the original mortgage generally remains in place. It typically lets the borrower draw funds up to a credit limit during a specified draw period. The balance can rise or fall as money is borrowed and repaid. Rates may be variable, and some HELOCs have different payment rules during the draw and repayment periods. The specific agreement controls.

Both options use the home as collateral. Falling behind can put the home at risk of foreclosure. Neither the amount of equity a homeowner has nor a calculator result establishes eligibility or the amount a lender will offer.

Costs and Key Differences

  • Existing mortgage: A refinance replaces it; a HELOC generally adds a separate lien and payment.
  • Access to money: A refinance generally provides a lump sum at closing. A HELOC can permit multiple draws, subject to its terms and available credit.
  • Interest structure: A refinance may have a fixed or adjustable rate. HELOC rates are often variable, but terms differ; check the contract rather than assuming.
  • Costs: Either transaction may involve lender charges and other closing costs. A HELOC can also have account-related fees. Request written cost details and compare them with the loan’s terms.
  • Payment uncertainty: A fixed-rate refinance can make principal-and-interest payments predictable, while a variable HELOC payment may change as rates or balances change. Taxes, insurance, and other housing costs can change separately.

Comparing monthly payments alone can mislead. A longer repayment term can lower the payment while increasing the time interest accrues. Compare the amount of cash received, total costs over the period you expect to keep the debt, repayment schedule, rate-change exposure, and consequences of borrowing against the home. Ask the lender for the actual figures; do not treat a sample APR or fee as a quote.

How to Compare the Options

Start by writing down the purpose and amount of borrowing, then request terms for each structure. For a refinance, identify the new loan balance, cash proceeds after payoff and costs, APR, term, and whether the rate is fixed. For a HELOC, ask about the credit limit, draw and repayment periods, rate index and margin, how the rate can change, payment calculation, fees, and any restrictions on draws.

For example, someone with a $250,000 mortgage who wants $30,000 cannot compare a $30,000 refinance calculation with a $30,000 HELOC payment and call the result complete. The refinance would generally need to cover the existing mortgage payoff as well as any financed costs and the cash-out amount. The HELOC, by contrast, may leave the first mortgage in place and add a separate balance. The relevant borrowing amounts and total obligations differ.

Use the calculator only as a simplified refinance-payment estimate. To compare total borrowing costs, include the existing mortgage’s remaining payments and the HELOC’s projected draws, rate changes, and payments. If those details are unknown, ask for illustrations under clearly stated assumptions rather than treating a single scenario as certain.

Common Misconceptions and Limits

“Home equity” is not cash that can be withdrawn automatically. A lender sets the terms and determines whether an application qualifies. Likewise, a low initial HELOC payment may not represent the payment later in repayment, particularly if the agreement permits interest-only payments initially or the rate changes.

Another misconception is that a cash-out refinance always has a lower total cost because it consolidates debt into one payment. It can change the rate or extend repayment on the entire mortgage balance, not just the cash borrowed. Conversely, a HELOC’s separate payment and variable-rate exposure can make its future cost less predictable. Compare the complete loan terms and costs, not just the number of payments or the advertised payment.

This calculator assumes a new, fixed-rate loan with equal monthly payments and no fees. It does not estimate cash proceeds, payoff amounts, taxes, lender approval, home value, or a HELOC. Its results are not a quote or a forecast of future variable rates.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a cash-out refinance the same as a HELOC?
No. A refinance replaces the existing mortgage with a new one; a HELOC is generally a separate credit line secured by the home.

Does a HELOC replace my mortgage?
Usually it does not: the existing mortgage generally stays in place, with the HELOC added as another loan. Confirm the structure and lien terms in the documents.

Can a HELOC have a variable interest rate?
Yes. Many HELOCs have variable rates, though terms vary. Review how the rate is determined, how often it can change, and how that affects payments.

Does this calculator show how much cash I will receive?
No. It estimates principal-and-interest payments and total interest for the new loan amount you enter. Cash proceeds depend on the mortgage payoff, transaction costs, and the lender’s terms.

What should I compare besides the monthly payment?
Compare cash received, total borrowing costs, fees, repayment period, rate-change risk, payment terms, and whether the existing mortgage is replaced or retained.

This result is an estimate; the lender’s disclosure gives the exact figures.

Related

Formula used
in p | New refinance loan amount | $ | 20000 | 1 | 100000000
in apr | Interest rate (APR) | % | 8 | 0.01 | 100
in yrs | Loan term | years | 5 | 0.0833 | 50
out pmt | Monthly payment | $ | p * (apr / 1200) / (1 - (1 + apr / 1200) ^ -(yrs * 12)) | 2
out int | Total interest | $ | pmt * yrs * 12 - p | 2

Each line is one input (in, sel, list) or one result (out: label, unit, formula, decimals). How the calculators work

Method: the standard loan formula for this calculation, fixed rate and monthly compounding unless stated, rounded as each result states. Not financial advice; no lender, rate or product is recommended. See formulas and assumptions, the disclaimer or report an error.

More in this section

The whole Loan payments section →